• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Evergreen Small Business

Actionable Insights from Small Business CPAs

  • Home
  • Small Business FAQ
  • Monographs
    • Maximizing PPP Loan Forgiveness
    • Preparing U.S. Tax Returns for International Taxpayers
    • Maximizing Sec. 199A Deductions Monograph
    • Setting Low Salaries for S Corporations
    • Small Business Tax Deduction Secrets
    • Real Estate Tax Loopholes & Secrets
    • Preparing Form 3115 for the Tangible Property Regulations
    • Small Businesses and the Affordable Care Act (Obamacare)
    • Five Minute Payroll Monograph (2019 Edition)
    • Download Your Free Copy of the Thirteen Word Retirement Plan
    • Business Planning Workbook
    • Sample Corporate Bylaws
    • LLC Operating Agreement
    • Joining Our Affiliate Program
  • Our Bloggers
  • Free LLC Formation Kits
    • Alabama LLC
    • Alaska LLC
    • Arizona LLC
    • Arkansas LLC
    • California LLC
    • Colorado LLC
    • Connecticut LLC
    • Delaware LLC
    • Florida LLC
    • Georgia LLC
    • Hawaii LLC
    • Idaho LLC
    • Illinois LLC
    • Indiana LLC
    • Iowa LLC
    • Kansas LLC
    • Kentucky LLC
    • Louisiana LLC
    • Maine LLC
    • Maryland LLC
    • Massachusetts LLC
    • Michigan LLC
    • Minnesota LLC
    • Mississippi LLC
    • Missouri LLC
    • Montana LLC
    • Nebraska LLC
    • Nevada LLC
    • New Hampshire LLC
    • New Jersey LLC
    • New Mexico LLC
    • New York LLC
    • North Carolina LLC
    • North Dakota LLC
    • Ohio LLC
    • Oklahoma LLC
    • Oregon LLC
    • Pennsylvania LLC
    • Rhode Island LLC
    • South Carolina LLC
    • South Dakota LLC
    • Tennessee LLC
    • Texas LLC
    • Utah LLC
    • Vermont LLC
    • Virginia LLC
    • Washington LLC
    • West Virginia LLC
    • Wisconsin LLC
    • Wyoming LLC
  • S Corporation Kits
    • Alabama S Corporation
    • Alaska S Corporation
    • Arizona S Corporation
    • Arkansas S Corporation
    • California S Corporation
    • Colorado S Corporation
    • Connecticut S Corporation
    • Delaware S Corporation
    • Florida S Corporation
    • Georgia S Corporation
    • Hawaii S Corporation
    • Idaho S Corporation
    • Illinois S Corporation
    • Indiana S Corporation
    • Iowa S Corporation
    • Kansas S Corporation
    • Kentucky S Corporation
    • Louisiana S Corporation
    • Maine S Corporation
    • Maryland S Corporation
    • Massachusetts S Corporation
    • Michigan S Corporation
    • Minnesota S Corporation
    • Mississippi S Corporation
    • Missouri S Corporation
    • Montana S Corporation
    • Nebraska S Corporation
    • Nevada S Corporation
    • New Hampshire S Corporation
    • New Jersey S Corporation
    • New Mexico S Corporation
    • New York S Corporation
    • North Carolina S Corporation
    • North Dakota S Corporation
    • Ohio S Corporation
    • Oklahoma S Corporation
    • Oregon S Corporation
    • Pennsylvania S Corporation
    • Rhode Island S Corporation
    • South Carolina S Corporation
    • South Dakota S Corporation
    • Tennessee S Corporation
    • Texas S Corporation
    • Utah S Corporation
    • Vermont S Corporation
    • Virginia S Corporation
    • Washington S Corporation
    • West Virgina S Corporation
    • Wisconsin S Corporation
    • Wyoming S Corporation
  • Contact Nelson CPA
You are here: Home / individual income taxes / Lottery Tax Planning for a Billion Dollar Drawing

Lottery Tax Planning for a Billion Dollar Drawing

January 11, 2023 By Stephen Nelson CPA

Lottery tax planning can save millionsOkay. This is silly. You’re probably not going to win. But just for fun, let’s talk about lottery tax planning for one of those giant Power Ball or Mega Millions lotteries. What should you do, tax-wise, if you win a billion dollars?

Quite a lot, actually. But let me explain.

Share Your Winnings

A first thing you want to do. Maybe. If you plan to share your winnings with heirs, gift an interest in your lottery ticket before the drawing.

A one quarter interest in a $2 Power Ball or Mega Millions ticket is worth $.50. That minimal amount can be given away without any gift tax consequences. An individual can give away up to $17,000 to someone without triggering gift taxes.

But if you win a $1,000,000,000 lottery? And then you give away a big chunk? Like a quarter interest?

You’ll pay roughly 40 percent in gift taxes. Give three heirs $100,000,000 each, for example, and you’ll pay $40 million in gift taxes, roughly, on each of those three gifts.

Note: If you don’t give away the money, it ends up in your estate. And then your estate pays roughly 40 percent in federal estate taxes. In many states, another chunk goes to state estate taxes. Washington state for example levies a 20 percent state estate tax. (More information here: How Washington State Estate Taxes Work  )

So anyway: That’s idea one. Share before you win.

Note: I have a standard agreement with my two kids. Every time I buy a lottery ticket, I gift each of them a one quarter share. Something I memorialize with a text message. And sure. It’s all just fun and games right now. But if I win? Yeah. Bingo.

Take the Lump Sum Payout

Here’s another lottery tax planning idea. And this is a bit controversial.

You have a choice to take your winnings as a lump sum or in thirty annual payments. The choice might be, for example, $500,000,000 up front. Or $1,000,000,000 paid out over three decades. (See here for a description of how the Mega Millions payout options work: https://www.megamillions.com/How-to-Play/Difference-Between-Cash-Value-and-Annuity.aspx )

I think you take the $500,000,000 if you live in a no or low income tax state. Or if you live in a state with income taxes but winning the lottery won’t cause you to move to a lower-tax state.

The reasoning behind this suggestion rests on two factors.

First factor? Today tax rates are still pretty low at a federal level. You’ll pay roughly 37 percent.

In 2026, however, the Trump tax cuts expire. And then the top tax rate jumps to 39.6%. A three-percent-ish bump doesn’t sound like a lot. But it adds tens of millions of dollars of taxes.

And then there’s a second reason to take a lump sum payout. Or at least seriously consider the lump-sum payout.

Stack Charitable Contributions in Year You Win

That reason? If you’re going to contribute any of the winnings to charity, you want to get that deduction onto a return when it’s fully deductible.

In 2023? A big charitable deduction works on your return. If you give away $50 million or $100 million? You deduct the $50 million or $100 million.

However, in 2026, tax law changes and essentially prevents or limits high income taxpayers from deducting charitable deductions.

The bottom line? You want to stack your charitable deductions in the year you win. And onto a tax return when you get a full deduction.

One other tip: You don’t want to overwhelm some small charity with a giant contribution. Further, you will want to do a thoughtful job of where and how and when you donate. That’s just good stewardship. Thus this companion idea: Probably you want to contribute your big charitable deduction to a charitable donor advised fund. (For example, Vanguard’s: Donor advised fund.) That gives you the deduction this year. And then you can, over time, smartly parcel out your gift to worthy recipients.

Note: Other tax accountants disagree with my suggestion to take the lump sum payout. And I”ll talk more about this in a minute.

Consider Post-Drawing Gifts

You can in 2023 give $17,000 in any given year to someone without paying gift tax.

If you’re married, your spouse can do the same.

Then over and above these limits, you can give away another $12,600,000 in gifts yourself over your lifetime. And then your spouse if you’re married can do the same.

Thus this idea: If you have other giving you want to do? Think about using the annual exclusion allowed (that $17,000 per person per year) to make gifts to friends and family.

And then think about using up the single $12,600,000 or the married $25,200,000 life-time exclusion.

Let’s say for example that you and your spouse have ten people—family members and friends—who you want to share your winnings with.

I think you give each of them 1/10th of your lifetime exclusion. So maybe that’s roughly $2.5 million a person.

What this maneuver saves? More estate and gift tax. And then one other thing. Maybe these gifts lessen the distance between you and your brother or dad. The distance created by you receiving a giant windfall, I mean. Just an idea.

Note that this option works when you take a lump sum payout. It probably doesn’t work or work well if you take the annuity.

Be Tax-efficient Investing Your Winnings

I have two final lottery tax planning ideas for you, too. Ideas connected to how you handle the remaining winnings in a tax-smart manner.

But let’s summarize the hypothetical situation. You won a $1,000,000,000 drawing but took the lump sum payment. So your billion-dollar ticket actually resulted in roughly a $500,000,000 payout.

You gifted interests in the ticket prior to the drawing to your kids. (That probably saves about $100,000,000 in federal estate taxes in the case where you win a “billion dollars” drawing.) And it means the $500,000,000 drops to $250,000,000.

On the $250,000,000, say you gave $25,000,000 to a charitable donor fund. That gift drops the balance in your bank account balance to $225,000,000. (But by making the deduction now you save roughly $9 million in federal income taxes. Stretch your giving out, however, and you’ll lose most of this.)

You will have paid maybe $90,000,000 in federal and state income taxes. That payment drops your bank account balance to roughly $135,000,000.

And so then, at that point, I think you invest the remaining funds using the recipe Warren Buffett has reportedly set up for his wife upon his passing. That recipe puts 90 percent of the investment into a US stock index fund and 10 percent into US Treasury bonds.

You and I should do something similar with a $100 million or $135 million portfolio.

The big tax reason for this suggestion? The income generated by such a portfolio would mostly be either untaxed or taxed at low rates. Appreciation in the stocks, for example, wouldn’t be taxed until you sell. And you might never sell.

Further, dividends and capital gains would probably be taxed at a federal rate of roughly 24 percent. (The sum of the top capital gains and qualified dividends tax rate, 20 percent, plus the net investment income tax rate, 3.8 percent.)

Consider Moving to Another State

Let me also throw out another lottery tax planning idea which is maybe a little less workable. But something to consider. You may want to move to a low or no-income-tax sate.

On a passive portfolio of $135,000,000 with a Warren Buffet allocation, your annual income might run roughly $3,000,000. (That’d be roughly $500,000 of interest and roughly $2.500,000 of dividends and long-term capital gains.) A Buffet style allocation would result in a federal tax burden of roughly $800,000. Or about 25 percent.

A handful of states don’t tax or mostly don’t tax investment income, however. Probably you living in one of those (Alaska, Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas, Washington, and Wyoming) will save you several hundred thousand dollars a year.

By the way, if you think you’ll move? The lump sum option possibly doesn’t make as much sense. This article explains why: Smart Tax Strategies for Lottery Winners.  But to summarize, the article authors point out that the implicit return someone earns by “investing” the lump sum payout into the annuity represents a decent return. (About 3.7% after taxes, I calculate.) An annuity maybe limits a winner’s ability to spend all the money quickly and foolishly. Finally, and I think this is really key, an annuity may provide for the opportunity to do something like move to another state. (This would make a big difference potentially.)

I agree with those points for small-ish lottery winners. For gigantic winners, my opinion, looking at the lump sum payout option makes sense.

Final Remarks Concerning Lottery Tax Planning

A couple of quick remarks in closing. First, the highest impact idea in the preceding paragraphs? A pre-drawing gift. That’s the lottery tax planning gambit you really want to consider. And that gambit illustrates a key tax planning reality: Up front planning often makes the biggest impact.

A second point: It probably makes sense to get a good tax accountant involved in your decision making once you win. The federal and state income and estate taxes get really big.

Filed Under: individual income taxes, personal finance

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Todd S Hyman says

    January 11, 2023 at 10:38 am

    I enjoyed this article very much. When I’m waiting in line to purchase my quick pick, I find myself thinking about how I would handle the taxs when I win as well
    I know that I will probably never win but you never know

    • Stephen Nelson CPA says

      January 11, 2023 at 12:30 pm

      We can’t win if we don’t play. Good luck!

  2. Dick T says

    January 11, 2023 at 12:42 pm

    Steve, it is probably the simplest to gift to your children. If you have more than two and some grandchildren, do you have thoughts on using a general partnership? I suppose asset protection is better if individuals are used. Using a Ltd partnership would seem to be more complicated than worthwhile since the chance of winning is unlikely.
    Thanks for your thoughts

    • Stephen Nelson CPA says

      January 11, 2023 at 1:04 pm

      I think you could use something like an LLC treated as a partnership. As long as that wasn’t too expensive to setup and operate.

      Idea: Put $100 into an partnership. Buy a $2 Power Ball or Mega Millions ticket everytime the jackpot hits $1,000,000,000?

      The advantage of using something like an LLC would mean managers could manage the funds for minors. And for special needs situations.

  3. Jerry Seo says

    January 11, 2023 at 1:49 pm

    Like Todd, I really enjoyed this article. Also bought some tickets for the big one. With that amount of money I would be hard pressed to think of ways to invest it. Real estate? Stocks? And keeping track of the investments would be a full time job in itself. I want to enjoy it, not work harder! So the suggestion of 90% in an index fund and 10% in US government bonds would be seriously considered. Definitely for my wife, who relies completely on me for all things financial.

    • Stephen Nelson CPA says

      January 11, 2023 at 4:26 pm

      Thanks for sharing Jerry. And I agree that with a really big balance, an asset allocation formula like Buffet suggested makes a lot more sense. If you’ve got $10M or $15M in treasuries… and then your other 90% in an institutional index fund? Seems pretty clean. 🙂

  4. Thao says

    January 11, 2023 at 1:59 pm

    Enjoyed reading your article. I am a tax accountant and as a rule usually advise clients to take a lump sum if offered and invest it. There is a risk of non-payment. Even if it means paying more in taxes. Money in your hands are surely worth something than not.

    • Stephen Nelson CPA says

      January 11, 2023 at 4:28 pm

      Thanks Thao. And like you, I thought taking the lump sum sort of a fairly orthodox idea. Thus I was surprised the Tax Advisor articles advised differently. As I noted in blog post, when I calculated the return on investment using the Mega Millions numbers from today, I got a 3.7% tax-free nominal rate. That’s decent. But not that great.

  5. Wendy Korman says

    January 12, 2023 at 6:45 am

    This is good to know for when I win on Friday! With that said, what about setting up a complex trust (i.e., The Lottery Winning Trust) with your favorite friends and your family members as beneficiaries. Fund the trust with a nominal amount and make sure to notate that the trust is buying the lottery ticket. Sign the back of the ticket as “The Lottery Winning Trust.” Have the trust report and pay the taxes and then distribute funds to the beneficiaries. Your thoughts?

    • Stephen Nelson CPA says

      January 17, 2023 at 3:54 pm

      Great idea Wendy. Now one of us just needs to win! 🙂

  6. Chanan Goldberg says

    January 17, 2023 at 8:59 am

    Enjoyed reading the article. I would think if it’s still early in the year, to become a real estate professional by quitting your job, use the money to invest in real estate with a high percentage in furniture and/or land improvement using the maximum mortgage possible (this would allow you to basically deduct your entire down payment using cost segregation and bonus depreciation), spend at least 750 hours on the real estate, and you will be able to avoid paying taxes on most of the earnings that year.

    • Stephen Nelson CPA says

      January 17, 2023 at 3:57 pm

      Yup, yup. That works if you meet the more than 750 hours and more than 50 percent of your time thresholds.

      More info here: Real estate professional

  7. Morgan says

    January 22, 2023 at 6:46 pm

    This article was super fun but now I think you should do a ‘if you win 3 million’ version. We have better odds of a smaller jackpot. 😉

    The spouse and I were discussing a smaller win the other day and I felt it likely that a median income family would do better over the long haul to take the annuity. That assumes the payments would stay in the 12% tax bracket so savings would be significant and there’s less a chance of windfall mismanagement….

    M.

    • Stephen Nelson CPA says

      January 23, 2023 at 3:08 pm

      I think you’re right that if a family could annuitize a, say, $3M jackpot over thirty years, it would make more sense to take annual payments. And for the reason you point to. Better to pay a low or middle tax rate on the winnings than mostly 37%.

Primary Sidebar

Welcome

Nelson CPA publishes this blog to help and encourage small business owners. Click here to learn more about our firm.

Need to help clients with their PPP loan forgiveness applications?

Updated for 2019 tax year changes and now available in print from Amazon!!

Maximizing Sec. 199A Deductions

International tax issues?

Preparing US tax returns for international taxpayers

Maximize S corporation tax savings

Setting Low S Corporation Salaries

Free retirement planning help

Picture of Thirteen Word Retirement Plan book

Featured Posts

Washington state capital gains tax returns will need to be filed for 2022 as per the Supreme Court's March decision.

Filing Washington State Capital Gains Tax Returns

You maybe need to file a Washington state capital gains tax return with your 2022 federal tax return. Specifically, if you realized long-term … [Read More...] about Filing Washington State Capital Gains Tax Returns

Working longer avoids sequence of returns risk

Working Longer Avoids Sequence of Returns Risk

The term “sequence of returns risk” refers to the risk that your retirement nest egg may not last if you get a bad patch of returns at the start of … [Read More...] about Working Longer Avoids Sequence of Returns Risk

How IRS audits work

How IRS Audits Work

Audit anxiety is something nearly every taxpayer has in common.  But, have you ever considered how IRS audits actually work? The IRS processes … [Read More...] about How IRS Audits Work

Recent Comments

  • Stephen Nelson CPA on Lottery Tax Planning for a Billion Dollar Drawing
  • Morgan on Lottery Tax Planning for a Billion Dollar Drawing
  • Stephen Nelson CPA on Lottery Tax Planning for a Billion Dollar Drawing
  • Stephen Nelson CPA on Lottery Tax Planning for a Billion Dollar Drawing
  • Chanan Goldberg on Lottery Tax Planning for a Billion Dollar Drawing

Archives

Copyright © 2023 Stephen L. Nelson, Inc. · News Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress